open All Channels
seplocked Jita Park Speakers Corner
blankseplocked CSM candidates - QUICK REFERENCE CARDS and spreadsheet - V.1.2
 
This thread is older than 90 days and has been locked due to inactivity.


 
Pages: 1 2 [3]

Author Topic

Veryez
Posted - 2008.05.10 21:59:00 - [61]
 

Originally by: Andargor theWise

Nice initiative, didn't know who to vote for.

Here's my contribution, a scorecard to pick candidates.

Self-explanatory, done really quickly, so no guarantee on accuracy, etc etc. Feel free to adjust and repost.

EDIT: Updated URL
EDIT2: Fixed Max and Noghri Embarassed



This was so very useful, thank you. It obviously works since it shows that Goum and I agree on almost nothing. Razz Having said that, I will say that Goum obviously spends a great deal of time researching before he opens his mouth, and he does seem very passionate about EvE - we just tend to have different opinions.

Actually it showed me aligned with the candidate who was among my top 3 choices. Thanks for spending your time doing this.

Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
Posted - 2008.05.11 08:49:00 - [62]
 

Updated the OP and thread title, added Andragor's contribution.
I don't think that I could have found a better way to express it in an easier form, I must admit I was thinking more of a color-coded square cell fields with questions on the side and candidate names on top... the spreadsheet is so much better and useful, no point altering it.

@Xaen : [sarcasm]Yeah, sorry for not being able to think about each and every detail on such a short notice, sorry for not also adding "fix lag" and "bugfix desynchs" to the list of brackets for the candidates, and finally sorry for not personally asking for everybody else's help and suggestions as to what other important brackets might be.[/sarcasm]

While a complete graphical UI revamp is also needed, it's mostly a technical issue rather than a game balance or game design issue. Yes, I have accidentally let ONE bracket that's a technical issue (the S&I interface revamp), but that was because it was presented alongside several other decent questions. I'm by no means a machine, so I do unavoidably end up making some mistakes.


Andargor theWise
Collateral Damage Unlimited
Posted - 2008.05.12 23:29:00 - [63]
 

Edited by: Andargor theWise on 12/05/2008 23:31:31

Spreadsheet Updated: Added Grey Shadow


Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
Posted - 2008.05.13 10:43:00 - [64]
 

Edited OP to include link to latest spreadsheet.
Thanks again Wink

Hardin
Amarr
Imperial Dreams
Curatores Veritatis Alliance
Posted - 2008.05.13 11:24:00 - [65]
 

[8] Rate your own free time in the real life (what's left after work, school, other obligation)
[2] Do you wish you didn't have to travel to Iceland for CSM meetings ?
[7] Rate your own forum reading presence
[6] Rate your own forum posting presence
[7] Rate your own ingame presence
[6] Rate your own PvP activity level
[3] Rate your own PvE activity level
[1] Rate your own industry/science/trade activity level
[3] Number of most accounts you ever had active at the same time
[5] Lowsec mining needs a boost
[5] Highsec mining needs a boost
[5] We need larger mining ships
[5] Rorquals should be allowed to use stargates like jump freighters
[0] Allow capital ships in highsec (cyno in highsec)
[5] Jump freighters need a big boost (extra cargo, extra hitpoints/resists, maybe even module/rig slots, whatever)
[5] Lowsec mission-running needs a boost
[6] Highsec mission-running needs a nerf
[5] Bring back nexus chip NPC buy orders
[0] L5 missions need to be available in highsec too
[5] L4 missions need to be available in lowsec only
[9] No insurance for CONCORD kills
[1] No insurance for 0.0 kills
[1] No insurance for Battlecruisers and above
[1] No insurance for Battleships and above
[5] Dysprosium situation is just fine, adapt or die
[7] Moon mining needs a total revamp
[7] Allow moon mining in 0.4
[2] Allow moon mining in highsec
[5] Input T1 BPC levels need to influence output T2 BPC levels
[5] You should be able to research levels on BPCs in POS mobile labs
[5] Mobile lab slots need to be allowed to become public
[1] You should be able to build outposts in any system that have no stations at all (no sov requirements)
[5] Local should be replaced with constellation chat
[5] Local should be replaced with region chat
[0] Local must go away completely
[6] Non-covops cloaks need stronger drawbacks/penalities (lock time, lock range, etc)
[5] Stealth bombers need a boost
[5] Black ops need a boost
[5] Marauders need a boost
[1] HICtors need a nerf
[7] You should be able to probe non-covops cloaked ships
[5] You should be able to probe all cloaked ships
[2] Speed-tanking needs a nerf for all ships (less overall speed)
[7] Speed-tanking needs a nerf for the larger ships only (BS speed much lower, BC speed lower, cruiser speed a bit lower)
[2] Active shield tanking needs a nerf
[2] Active armor tanking needs a nerf
[2] Passive shield tanking needs a nerf
[2] Armor/hull buffer tanking needs a nerf
[3] Web drones need a boost
[3] Painter drones need a boost
[2] ECM drones need a nerf
[2] ECMs need a nerf
[2] RSDs need a nerf
[2] Carriers need a nerf
[2] Motherships need a nerf
[7] Titans need a nerf
[2] Focus fire needs a nerf
[2] Rigs on small ships need to cost less than rigs on large ships
[2] T1 rigs are too expensive
[2] T2 rigs are too expensive
[5] Abandoned wrecks should be scannable via probes
[5] Salvaging a wreck needs to be an act of agression
[5] Looting a wreck needs to not be an act of agression
[2] Older characters should be expelled from NPC corps in single-man corps
[2] Wardec fees are way too low for corps
[7] Wardec fees are way too low for alliances
[1] People should NOT be allowed to leave a wardecced corp until war ends
[1] Corps should NOT be allowed to leave a wardecced alliance until war ends
[7] More PVE content for small groups
[7] More PVP content for small groups
[5] Transferable killrights or other bounty system revamps
[5] Add additional rewards for killing outlaws
[5] Total revamp of Sci&Ind interface
[2] Remove all T2 BPOs
[6] Add ways to get new T2 BPOs

Serenity Steele
Dynamic Data Distribution
Posted - 2008.05.13 22:45:00 - [66]
 

CANDIDATE NAME : Shayne Smart
COUNTRY OF ORIGIN : Netherlands

[6] Rate your own free time in the real life (what's left after work, school, other obligation)
[0] Do you wish you didn't have to travel to Iceland for CSM meetings ?
[7] Rate your own forum reading presence
[6] Rate your own forum posting presence
[6] Rate your own ingame presence
[2] Rate your own PvP activity level
[6] Rate your own PvE activity level
[7] Rate your own industry/science/trade activity level
[5] Number of most accounts you ever had active at the same time
[6] Lowsec mining needs a boost
[2] Highsec mining needs a boost
[0] We need larger mining ships
[0] Rorquals should be allowed to use stargates like jump freighters
[0] Allow capital ships in highsec (cyno in highsec)
[5] Jump freighters need a big boost (extra cargo, extra hitpoints/resists, maybe even module/rig slots, whatever)
[6] Lowsec mission-running needs a boost
[7] Highsec mission-running needs a nerf
[5] Bring back nexus chip NPC buy orders
[0] L5 missions need to be available in highsec too
[6] L4 missions need to be available in lowsec only
[9] No insurance for CONCORD kills
[0] No insurance for 0.0 kills
[0] No insurance for Battlecruisers and above
[0] No insurance for Battleships and above
[7] Dysprosium situation is just fine, adapt or die
[7] Moon mining needs a total revamp
[6] Allow moon mining in 0.4
[0] Allow moon mining in highsec
[7] Input T1 BPC levels need to influence output T2 BPC levels
[6] You should be able to research levels on BPCs in POS mobile labs
[9] Mobile lab slots need to be allowed to become public
[0] You should be able to build outposts in any system that have no stations at all (no sov requirements)
[8] Local should be replaced with constellation chat
[0] Local should be replaced with region chat
[5] Local must go away completely
[7] Non-covops cloaks need stronger drawbacks/penalities (lock time, lock range, etc)
[7] Stealth bombers need a boost
[5] Black ops need a boost
[5] Marauders need a boost
[5] HICtors need a nerf
[8] You should be able to probe non-covops cloaked ships
[2] You should be able to probe all cloaked ships
[5] Speed-tanking needs a nerf for all ships (less overall speed)
[5] Speed-tanking needs a nerf for the larger ships only (BS speed much lower, BC speed lower, cruiser speed a bit lower)
[5] Active shield tanking needs a nerf
[5] Active armor tanking needs a nerf
[5] Passive shield tanking needs a nerf
[5] Armor/hull buffer tanking needs a nerf
[7] Web drones need a boost
[7] Painter drones need a boost
[5] ECM drones need a nerf
[5] ECMs need a nerf
[5] RSDs need a nerf
[3] Carriers need a nerf
[4] Motherships need a nerf
[3] Titans need a nerf
[2] Focus fire needs a nerf
[7] Rigs on small ships need to cost less than rigs on large ships
[4] T1 rigs are too expensive
[3] T2 rigs are too expensive
[8] Abandoned wrecks should be scannable via probes
[3] Salvaging a wreck needs to be an act of agression
[7] Looting a wreck needs to not be an act of agression
[7] Older characters should be expelled from NPC corps in single-man corps
[8] Wardec fees are way too low for corps
[8] Wardec fees are way too low for alliances
[1] People should NOT be allowed to leave a wardecced corp until war ends
[1] Corps should NOT be allowed to leave a wardecced alliance until war ends
[7] More PVE content for small groups
[9] More PVP content for small groups
[9] Transferable killrights or other bounty system revamps
[9] Add additional rewards for killing outlaws
[7] Total revamp of Sci&Ind interface
[0] Remove all T2 BPOs
[8] Add ways to get new T2 BPOs

Silenciel
ICE is Coming to EVE
Posted - 2008.05.15 10:07:00 - [67]
 

No more answer ?

Too bad, it was a good idea to make a base for more restricted choice of candidates.

Thanks for 28 who have answered (i'll vote for one of you).

Kaito Rei
Gallente
Kentucky Fried Capitals
Posted - 2008.05.15 17:18:00 - [68]
 

Originally by: Siigari Kitawa
Originally by: SencneS
[0] Salvaging a wreck needs to be an act of aggression
[9] Looting a wreck needs to not be an act of aggression
Means you want to salvage and loot, free of risk. ugh

WRECKS, not cans.

If you loot somebody's can yeah, you're open game.

But when you think about it, looting somebody's wreck is what causes half of highsec mission runner grief anyway. Additionally, if they don't loot and leave it's public.

Wrecks are not cargo containers.



Wich makes actually no sense, cause not everybody can afford the marauder to loot and salvage while still flying the mission.
If i fly a mission i make bookmarks and once it is completed i salvage and loot the stages.
But here comes the clue: those sick griefers scan my mission while i still fly it and salvage before i even finish it.
and now wheres the point in allowing them even to loot when i didn't even have the chance to do anything against it.

to be honest i dont really care much, but it still sucks.
and i'm totaly against making it even easier for them.

Viqtoria
Caldari
Perkone
Posted - 2008.05.16 23:23:00 - [69]
 

Originally by: TeddyBr FTW
Darius JOHNSON (CEO of Goons) has refused to answer these questions.

People need to put his answer into the mix when they make up their mind on who to vote.


Originally by: Darius JOHNSON
Originally by: TeddyBr FTW
Please go HERE and fill us in on all those issues.


Translation: Please spend an hour of your time filling out an extremely long report card using arbitrary numbers as a measurement for your pretend support on various issues the maker of the rather long report card finds it necessary to have arbitrary figures for whether or not the "issues" are even really clear.




so he hasn't wasted his time putting a numerical torrent of numbers into boxes that noone with a brain will read as they are not even slightly indicative of any ability to think about complex game balance issues? but oh wait you are that guy who has a HUGE grudge agains goonswarm for blowing up your mining ships over and over and over again, not at all biased are you :)


Pages: 1 2 [3]

This thread is older than 90 days and has been locked due to inactivity.


 


The new forums are live

Please adjust your bookmarks to https://forums.eveonline.com

These forums are archived and read-only